One of the great pleasures of reading and re-reading is encountering conceptual connections between authors and works that you may have never considered in common. I had one of these experiences recently while reading a short book about Dante. While working through the author's discussion of Monarchia and its relation to the Purgatorio, I found myself thinking that in some respects Dante's dualistic political philosophy anticipated important elements in Kant's short monograph Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals and his essays "What Is Enlightenment?", "The Idea for a Universal History with a Cosmopolitan Intent," and "Toward Perpetual Peace."
Showing posts with label Dante. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Dante. Show all posts
Wednesday, June 6, 2018
Thursday, June 18, 2015
Dante and Human Contentment in Paradiso
What expresses the fulfillment of the highest hope for human
existence? One way to answer this
question is to examine conceptions of blessedness such as heaven or
nirvana. Both are, traditionally
conceived, dimensions in which there is no more striving, in which there is
true contentment. In Paradiso
3.63-66, Dante observes that there is a hierarchy in heaven, and he asks
Piccarda Donati whether she longs to be higher in heaven than she is and closer to the
blazon light of the empyrean, God:
But tell me, do you, who are here
content,
Desire to achieve a higher place,
where you
Might still see more and make
yourself more dear?
(Paradiso 3.63-66; trans. Hollander)
Her response tells us, who might wonder about real joy in our lives, something about where true joy might be found, not only in heaven but also here and
now.
Thursday, May 21, 2015
Dante and Forgiveness in Purgatorio
Is forgiveness, for Dante, the most radical form of freedom and the fullest expression of love? I believe that it is, although not precisely as some readers of Dante sometimes argue. I have in mind in particular the overstatement of forgiveness in terms of the existentialist reading that I perceive permeates some contemporary readings of the Commedia.
Friday, October 31, 2014
Dante and Virgil: Learning from Others
To what degree can, or should, we learn from others
different from ourselves? Particularly, how much can, or should, we learn about
the path that we believe we must take from those who have chosen a different
path? This is a question as much about
social relations and integrated thinking as it is about personal identity and
self-discovery.
In Dante’s Inferno, Canto
1, Dante affirms that Virgil is his guide and teacher:
'You are my teacher and my
author.
You are the one from whom alone I
took
the noble style that has brought me
honor.
(Inferno, 1.85-87; all
references to Hollander trans.)
Here Dante refers to his prior poetic writings. The implication is that Dante will also
inform the current poetic enterprise with its subject matter. This is somewhat
curious because also in the first canto we read that Virgil will not be
Dante’s guide in the last stage of his journey upward to
“His city” (l. 126). The reason Virgil
gives is that he is not worthy to guide Dante through paradiso to God,
and the reason for his unworthiness is that Virgil himself strayed from the
righteous path that Dante seeks to find:
'Should you desire to ascend to
these,
you'll find a soul more fit
to lead than I:
I'll leave you in her care
when I depart.
'For the Emperor who has His
seat on high
wills not, because I was a
rebel to His law,
that I should make my way
into His city.
(Inferno, 1.121-126)
Despite Virgil’s spiritual state as a reprobate, as a rebel,
as someone in other words who did not bend his will to God and who did not
follow his righteous path, Virgil himself asserts that he is, however, fit to instruct and lead Dante through hell:
'Therefore, for your sake, I think
it wise
you follow me: I will be your guide
(Inferno, 1.112-13)
Yes, we learn later in the Inferno that God had commissioned Virgil for this task. In Inferno
canto 2, we learn that this commission came through three heavenly ladies, but
the point is that Virgil bears God’s authority when interacting with
inhabitants of hell at various stages.
My own reflections about my current identity development and
self-discovery prompted these thoughts as I recently read Dante’s Inferno:
Virgil the pagan poet is authoritatively permitted, commissioned, to
instruct Dante in his pursuit of light and righteousness. Virgil may have been opposite to God but yet
still may be a reliable guide -- in fact, a heaven-sent guide. The pagan poet acts as pedagogue to the
spiritual pilgrim.
So again, the particular related struggle or question: What and how can I learn about the path I
must take from those who have chosen a different path?
This question strikes me as one of universal concern. It assumes that we are all wrestling with the
question of self, of our own respective identities, while at the same time
locating ourselves in connection with (and distinction from) others, even
others not of our “circle.” Or we are
negotiating ever expanding circles. What
is the proper relationship? How close is
too close? Will I be influenced overly
by their decisions rather than finding the proper balance between their ideas
and my own?
| Dante and Virgil, rendered by Botticelli |
In my own life, I am currently near that midpoint, just as
Dante was, the nel mezzo. I am trying to ask from familiar and
unfamiliar points of view big questions about God (nature, revealed truth), about
God’s relations to humans (of what sort is it?), about human nature and the
relation of the mind to both the brain (is there really anything that is a “mind”?
Is it somehow distinct from the physical brain and chemical reactions?), and about
the nature of morality in general and its relationship to God in particular
(what is the precise connection? Is there a necessary foundation?).
In asking these and other questions, I find that I must
necessarily do at least two things. (1) I must reevaluate what I believe by
taking stock first of what I actually think (perhaps with greater precision
than I hitherto have or have in some while, a valuable enterprise itself). And (2) I must weigh that review against the
ideas of others who have followed paths that I have not before trodden. Is it
better? If not, why is it worse? What to pursue, what to avoid? What to retain, what to reject?
Of late in my own life have been wondering how modern
neuroscientific conceptions of the brain bear on questions of human sinfulness,
ethical behavior and responsibility, and the need for salvation at all. Physiologically,
what goes into cognition and moral judgment?
What implications might there be, if any, on various religious belief if
philosophical and psychological theories about the modular mind and the lack of
anything like a singular “self” prove to be true? What of the question of chemical explanations
for innate ideas of transcendence and the divine?
The upshot, and the connection between Dante’s poem and my
own external context (and perhaps one of universal concern) is the extent to
which I can learn from guides or teachers not within my circle and yet continue
to follow the righteous, God-approved path.
Dante altered his path, and in so doing also altered his conception of
himself -- at least expanding it. For
Dante in the dark wood of the mid point of his life, it was not a matter of
interacting with things like ancient Chinese thought or neuroscience. But on his path he was surprised to find
Virgil as his guide through the Inferno,
a guide limited to a portion of the journey, but reliable nevertheless and
divinely commissioned however different from Dante he may have been. But Dante the poet was also relieved and
encouraged to find his guide to be Virgil, the Roman poet par excellence. And it may be that certain connections are
more important than differences to initiate our exploration of both.
How may I learn from Virgil without befalling his fate? That is perhaps one of Dante’s questions, and it is,
metaphorically, mine and, in one way or another, also all of ours.
Thursday, October 30, 2014
Dante at the end of Vita Nuova
I have recently been digging into Dante, which, I am ashamed
to say, I have never really explored previously. I started with Inferno, and then returned to an earlier work, La Vita Nuova (“The New Life”).
A question that is preoccupying me is the extent to which Dante develops
the idea of the self in his poetry.
![]() |
| Dante encountering Beatrice |
This is a notion that one might read consistent with the
Catholic western tradition of Augustine of Hippo’s Confessions. This is a
religious meditation that has, among other things, as its effect the production
of religious autobiography for spiritually edifying purposes, both within
oneself and within others. On the other
hand, there can be a tendency to read Dante, and particularly the Commedia with such a concern for “self-actualization”
or “self-discovery” that it seems like Dante’s concern is more naturally at
home in the Enlightenment or later French existentialism than in Renaissance
Italy. About this I am suspicious, but
still undecided.
At the end of Vita
Nuova, which preceded the publication of The Divine Comedy by at least 13 years, what portrait of Dante
emerges? What do we learn about the pre-Inferno Dante?
We glimpse in the Vita
Nuova a poet who, on the one hand, is still enamored of Beatrice as he was
at the beginning of his prosimetrum
work of courtly love, but who, on the other hand, seems confused about her and
his relationship to her. Indeed, he
seems confused about himself.
In chapter 42 we read of his fixation and vision; we also
read of his uncertainty how to describe or to understand this view of Beatrice:
After I wrote this sonnet there came to me a miraculous vision
in which I saw things that made me resolve to say no more about this blessed
one until I would be capable of writing about her in a nobler way. To achieve
this I am striving as hard as I can, and this she truly knows. Accordingly, if
it be the pleasure of Him through whom all things live that my life continue
for a few more years, I hope to write of her that which has never been written
of any other woman.
Not only does Dante seem to believe that the late Beatrice
still has consciousness (“and this she truly knows” -- present tense). He
also seems to reflect either his own poetic incapacity at present to write of
her or his uncertainty about what it all means:
“until I would be capable of writing about her in a nobler way.” Does “in a nobler way” mean his poetic
technique? Or does it refer to his own
disposition and needing to mature in his feelings and expression beyond the raw
and still searching emotions that he has now?
Or both?
When he does write about her again later in the Commedia, will she still be the object
of his desire? Or will his desires have changed, his preoccupations?
It may be, as it seems to me, that in both the Vita Nuova and the later Commedia, in their own respective ways, Beatrice
serves the purpose of helping Dante to give voice to his own misgivings about
his life and its proper direction.
At the end of Vita Nuova, in any event, Dante still
seems to be searching for himself and his voice. In other words, he seems to be searching for
a beginning, a new life of poetic and self expression.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

